Sexual Abuse & the Bystander Effect: Why Silence Hurts
Sexual Abuse & the Bystander Effect: Why Silence Hurts
Trigger warning: This article discusses sexual assault, rape, sexual abuse, trauma and victimisation.
There are some stories that make you angry.
And then there are stories that make you sit there staring at your phone thinking, Surely this cannot be real.
The Cornell 7 case is one of those stories.
In 2024, a Cornell University student, referred to publicly as Jane Doe, alleged that she was drugged and sexually assaulted by multiple members of the Chi Phi fraternity. A civil lawsuit filed later alleged that messages about what was happening were circulating in a fraternity Snapchat group containing roughly 50 people. The case has since received renewed attention, and prosecutors have reopened the criminal investigation.
And that is where I want to talk about something that goes beyond the seven men accused of assault.
I want to talk about the bystander effect.
Because sexual abuse doesn’t happen in a vacuum.
Sometimes there is the person committing the abuse.
Sometimes there is the person being abused.
And sometimes there is a whole bloody audience.
The Cornell 7 case: when a group chat becomes part of the story
I want to be careful here because this is an active legal matter, and allegations are not the same thing as convictions.
But the reported facts are disturbing enough without embellishment.
According to the lawsuit and reporting, messages were circulating in a fraternity Snapchat group while the alleged assault was taking place. One message reportedly announced that there was a woman upstairs and invited others to participate. Another later asked whether the “shop” was still open. The group reportedly contained around 50 people, and researchers writing about the case have noted that none of the members reported the incident to police.
That is the part I keep coming back to.
Not just What did the seven accused men allegedly do?
But:
What happens psychologically when dozens of people see something wrong and nobody acts?
Because that is the bystander effect in its ugliest form.
We like to imagine that if we witnessed something horrific, we would immediately become the hero.
We would kick down the door.
We would call the police.
We would scream, STOP!
We would somehow find ourselves equipped with a cape and excellent crisis-management skills.
But real human behaviour is much messier.
People freeze.
People rationalise.
People assume someone else will intervene.
People worry about social consequences.
People don’t want to get involved.
People convince themselves that perhaps they misunderstood what they saw.
And sometimes people know exactly what is happening and still choose silence.
That is why bystander intervention matters so much.
The bystander effect isn’t an excuse
Understanding the bystander effect is important.
But understanding something does not mean excusing it.
Research into bystander intervention around sexual violence has identified barriers that can prevent people from intervening, including failing to recognise that a situation carries a risk of sexual violence. Research with Australian university students has similarly examined missed opportunities and barriers to intervention.
So yes, psychology helps explain why people freeze.
But at some point we also have to ask:
What are we teaching people to do when someone else is being harmed?
Because “I didn’t know what to do” cannot become the permanent cultural response to sexual abuse.
We need to teach people what to do.
Distract.
Interrupt.
Ask if someone is okay.
Get security.
Call emergency services.
Tell someone who can help.
Document what is happening when it is safe to do so.
Support the person afterwards.
And sometimes simply say:
“This isn’t okay.”
You don’t need to be Batman.
You just need to refuse to become part of the furniture.
“It’s not all men” — I understand the statement, but that’s not the point
Whenever women talk about sexual violence, someone inevitably appears with:
“Not all men.”
Yes.
I know.
Not all men commit sexual assault.
Not all men sexually harass women.
Not all men exploit vulnerable women.
Not all men participate in rape culture.
Not all men are perpetrators.
But if your first response to a conversation about sexual violence is to make sure nobody accidentally thinks you are one of the bad ones, perhaps ask yourself why.
Because the conversation isn’t actually about whether every individual man is guilty.
It’s about what all of us are willing to tolerate, challenge and change.
The Cornell case has made the bystander question particularly uncomfortable because the reporting has drawn attention not only to the men accused of assault, but also to the wider group chat and the institutional response that followed. Cornell says it sanctioned students involved, while reporting has raised questions about whether the response was sufficient and whether all relevant evidence reached prosecutors.
So when I say “it’s all of us”, I don’t mean every man is a rapist.
I mean all of us are responsible for the culture we participate in.
Men.
Women.
Friends.
Universities.
Families.
Workplaces.
Parents.
Teachers.
Therapists.
Institutions.
Everyone.
Because culture is built out of tiny decisions.
What we laugh at.
What we ignore.
Who we believe.
Who we protect.
Who we call “dramatic.”
Who we tell to calm down.
Who we tell not to ruin someone’s reputation.
Who we tell to be nice.
And that last one really gets me.
Women are taught to be nice even when the situation is already unsafe
I work with women around relationships, sexuality, boundaries and intimacy, and one pattern comes up again and again:
women are often incredibly well trained at making other people comfortable.
Don’t be rude.
Don’t embarrass him.
Don’t make a scene.
Don’t overreact.
Give him another chance.
Maybe he didn’t mean it.
Smile.
Be polite.
Don’t create an awkward situation.
Meanwhile…
THE SITUATION HAS ALREADY BEEN CREATED.
If someone is making unwanted sexual advances, ignoring your “no”, invading your space, pressuring you, touching you without consent or continuing after you’ve made your discomfort clear, you did not create the situation by objecting to it.
Their behaviour created the situation.
Your boundary is the response.
That distinction matters enormously.
I’ve worked with people who have spent years wondering whether they were “too sensitive” because they felt uncomfortable about something that happened to them.
And this is where I want women to become a little less concerned about being liked.
Not cruel.
Not abusive.
Not reckless.
Just less available for bullshit.
Welcome to the “dark era”
I actually love the internet’s obsession with the “dark feminine”, “villain era” and “bitch era” — provided we use the idea intelligently.
Because sometimes a woman doesn’t need another lesson in how to be softer.
She needs permission to say:
No.
No explanation.
No seventeen-paragraph justification.
No smile afterwards.
No apology.
No “sorry, but…”
Just:
No.
Your dark era doesn’t have to mean becoming a terrible person.
It can mean becoming a woman who no longer sacrifices her safety to protect someone else’s feelings.
It can mean becoming comfortable with being perceived as rude.
It can mean leaving the party.
Blocking the number.
Calling someone out.
Getting your friend out of the room.
Reporting harassment.
Refusing to laugh at the sexist joke.
Walking away from someone who makes your nervous system scream.
And yes — sometimes it means fighting back.
But “fighting back” doesn’t always mean physically fighting.
It can mean using your voice, your boundaries, your money, your vote, your platform, your community, your professional influence and your refusal to participate.
That is activism too.
“But what if people think I’m crazy?”
They might.
Women have been called crazy for centuries.
At this point, frankly, we have bigger things to worry about.
One of the most powerful things you can do after experiencing sexual harassment or abuse is to start separating what actually happened from what you think everyone else will think about what happened.
Those are two completely different questions.
Did someone cross my boundary?
And:
Will people think I’m dramatic if I say something?
The first question is about reality.
The second is about social conditioning.
And unfortunately, many women are much more practised at answering the second one.
Why survivors sometimes don’t report immediately
This is another part of sexual abuse that people desperately need to understand.
A survivor doesn’t necessarily respond to trauma by immediately standing up, pointing at the perpetrator and delivering a flawless police statement.
Sometimes the response is:
“Maybe it wasn’t that bad.”
Then:
“Maybe I misunderstood.”
Then:
“I don’t want to ruin his life.”
Then:
“I don’t want anyone to know.”
Then:
“I’ll just forget about it.”
And sometimes:
“Maybe if I act normally, it will feel normal.”
That last one is particularly important.
A person may continue being polite to an abuser.
They may reply to their messages.
They may even joke with them.
They may continue seeing them.
They may minimise what happened.
They may change their story as they slowly understand what happened to them.
None of that automatically means the abuse didn’t happen.
Trauma can be confusing.
The nervous system doesn’t always respond in the neat, logical sequence that other people expect.
Some people freeze.
Some people dissociate.
Some people appease.
Some people try to keep the perpetrator happy because their body has calculated that keeping the situation calm is safer than escalating it.
And sometimes survivors need time before they can even call something abuse.
That’s one reason victim blaming is so damaging.
We’re essentially asking someone who has just experienced something overwhelming to behave like a perfectly calm lawyer, detective and psychologist simultaneously.
Human beings don’t work like that.
Trauma doesn’t always look like trauma
One of the things I see in my work is that people can function remarkably well while carrying enormous amounts of unresolved trauma.
They go to work.
They exercise.
They date.
They have relationships.
They laugh.
They have sex.
They build businesses.
They become mothers.
They look completely fine.
And then their body says:
“Actually, we’re not fine.”
Sexual trauma can show up through hypervigilance, emotional numbness, dissociation, difficulty trusting, difficulty setting boundaries, fear around intimacy, changes in libido or difficulty feeling safe in your body.
This is why I wrote about emotional processing and regaining sexual sensitivity — because healing isn’t always about simply remembering what happened.
Sometimes it is about helping your body understand that the danger has passed.
I don’t want women to become afraid of all men
And this is where I want to make an important distinction.
My answer to sexual abuse isn’t:
“Men are dangerous. Avoid them all.”
I don’t believe that.
My answer is:
Know what safe behaviour looks like.
Learn to recognise red flags.
Know your boundaries.
Trust discomfort.
Pay attention to how someone responds to your “no.”
Watch how they treat people who have less power than them.
Notice whether they respect boundaries when nobody is watching.
And pay attention to how a man talks about women when he thinks there are no women listening.
Because character isn’t what someone says about themselves.
It’s what they do when they could get away with something.
And equally important:
look at what the people around him tolerate.
A person’s social environment tells you a lot.
We need more people willing to be uncomfortable
I sometimes think we are far too obsessed with comfort.
We don’t want awkward conversations.
We don’t want to offend anyone.
We don’t want to be “political.”
We don’t want to make people uncomfortable.
We don’t want to be called feminists.
We don’t want to be called angry.
We don’t want to be called bitter.
We don’t want to be called difficult.
Fine.
I’ll happily be difficult.
Because some conversations are supposed to be uncomfortable.
Activism is uncomfortable.
Talking about rape is uncomfortable.
Talking about patriarchy is uncomfortable.
Talking about institutional failures is uncomfortable.
Calling out your friend is uncomfortable.
Telling a man that his joke isn’t funny is uncomfortable.
Believing a woman when she’s telling you something painful is sometimes uncomfortable.
But discomfort is not the same thing as danger.
And sometimes the people laughing at activists are laughing because the activists are saying something they don’t want to hear.
People often prefer the person who keeps the peace to the person who tells the truth.
History is full of examples of why that isn’t necessarily a compliment.
What can I actually do if I see sexual harassment or abuse?
You don’t have to become a superhero.
You can start small.
If someone is being harassed:
Check in.
“Are you okay?”
Interrupt.
“Hey, come with me for a second.”
Distract.
Create a reason for the person to leave the situation.
Get help.
Security, staff, friends, emergency services or another trusted person.
Speak up.
“This isn’t appropriate.”
Support the survivor.
Listen without interrogating them.
Don’t turn it into an investigation about whether they’re telling the truth.
Don’t pressure them to report before they’re ready.
Don’t contact the perpetrator yourself if doing so could put the survivor at greater risk.
And if you’re the person experiencing abuse, you don’t have to figure out your entire life tonight.
One step is enough.
Tell one safe person.
Write down what happened.
Seek professional support.
Create physical distance where possible.
Learn your options.
And remember:
You are allowed to take your own experience seriously.
This is why I care about boundaries so much
Boundaries aren’t just something we talk about in relationship therapy because it’s trendy on Instagram.
They’re protective.
They’re about understanding where you end and another person begins.
I’ve written more about setting healthy boundaries because I believe boundaries are one of the foundations of healthy relationships. They aren’t walls designed to keep everyone out. They are guidelines for how we expect to be treated.
And if you’ve experienced sexual abuse, boundaries can become particularly complicated.
You may have learned to ignore your own discomfort.
You may have learned to appease.
You may have learned that saying “no” creates consequences.
You may have learned to prioritise another person’s emotional state over your own safety.
Healing can involve slowly unlearning those patterns.
How I work with survivors of sexual abuse
This is also where my work as a therapist comes into the picture.
I work with survivors of sexual abuse and sexual trauma, and I don’t believe healing means simply telling someone to “move on.”
There can be layers of shame, anger, fear, grief, body disconnection, relationship difficulties and confusion to work through.
In my practice, I use trauma-informed approaches that can include emotional processing, Inner Child Work, values work, self-esteem work and other therapeutic techniques depending on the individual.
My sex therapy service also supports people who have experienced rape or sexual assault and are dealing with flashbacks, dissociation, intimacy difficulties or difficulty feeling safe in their sexuality.
And for some people, Internal Family Systems Therapy can provide another way of understanding the different parts of themselves that developed around trauma, boundaries, trust and self-protection.
There is no single “correct” way to heal.
And there is certainly no deadline.
We don’t need more polite silence
The Cornell case has forced a lot of people to ask uncomfortable questions about sexual violence, bystander behaviour and institutional accountability.
The criminal investigation is now being revisited, so I am deliberately not pretending that I know the final legal outcome. But whatever ultimately happens in court, there is already a broader conversation we need to have about what happens before a case ever reaches a courtroom.
What are we teaching young men about women?
What are we teaching young women about boundaries?
What happens when someone sees something wrong?
What happens when a survivor speaks?
What happens when an institution has a reputation to protect?
And what happens when everyone decides that somebody else will deal with it?
That last question scares me the most.
Because the opposite of abuse isn’t simply “good people.”
The opposite of abuse is accountability.
It is people willing to interrupt.
People willing to believe.
People willing to report.
People willing to listen.
People willing to challenge their friends.
People willing to tolerate being called rude.
People willing to have difficult conversations.
People willing to say:
“No. We’re not doing this anymore.”
So yes, ladies.
Find your dark era.
Find your boundaries.
Find your voice.
Find your community.
Stop worrying quite so much about whether you’re being “nice” when someone is actively making you uncomfortable.
You don’t have to become cruel.
You don’t have to hate men.
You don’t have to live in fear.
You just have to stop abandoning yourself to keep everybody else comfortable.
And when you see something wrong?
Don’t become another person standing silently in the group chat.
Speak.
Act.
Interrupt.
Support.
Report when it is safe to do so.
Because change rarely starts with everyone agreeing.
It starts with somebody deciding:
I’m not going to look away.
If this article brought something up for you
If you have experienced sexual abuse or sexual assault, you don’t have to process it alone.
At Love Empowerment Clinic, I work with people around sexual trauma, intimacy, boundaries, relationships and emotional healing. You can learn more about my approach to sexual trauma and sex therapy or explore my resources for sexual trauma survivors.
If you are in immediate danger or need urgent support, please contact your local emergency service or a specialist sexual assault service.
You don’t have to be “over it” before you deserve support.